ChrisM wrote:Still hold there price better than the Renault, the diesel we where looking at had 85k on it at a price of £5980 spondoolies which I thought was a bit over the top for that millage it drove really nice mind you, roof was off in a jiffy without a single sound, seat where comfy ride was taut but no over hard, seem to handle quite nice, more room in the rear only slightly but never the less it was there, and nice little touches that Renault havn't botherd with like the passenger grab handles on the rear seat cards to help you out of that rear seat, Renault didn't bother so your rear seat passenger has nothing to pull on, usually grabbing that rear quater light glass for some pull, after driving it I do think the Pug pips the Renault at the 04/05 level as the pug was 05 mine is 04, front doors also had a better opening and closing handle to control them, I find the Renaults to close to the hindges really you don't have a lot of control over that hefty door, we had an ex Peugeot service adviser here for a while and he said the best pug CC to go for is the 20x range as the 30x range leak and do have roof issues yet the 20x range seem to be problem free and leak free, he said there is quite a differance between them but I think the 20x range is a bit small for me, I find pug pedals to small and close together to be honest, with my big plates of meat i keep pressing either brake and clutch together or brake and throttle either way not a good driving experiance for the passenger.
Just think that £6k on 85k is a lot of cash for the pug, I paid for an 04 car with 41k on it £5.5k, mine is just at the end of its 2nd year and has 80k on it now so obviously it is not for me er in doors fancied it until the miles blew it away, keep trying to get her into a Beetle 1.9TDi but the problem is finding one with a decent millage and not gallactic, did spot a superb 04 orange 2.0ltr Renault Sport with 40k on her for £5k, road tax hurt a bit, insurance wasn't to bad topping just over the £300 mark fully comp but mpg!!!!! on a good day they reckon around 33 which you wont get for the first year anyway as you will be hoofing this toy every where you go possibly more like 22mpg, shame really it was a lot of car for £5k and purrrfect condition. So it seems she is staying with her 99 V reg Coup after all for now, which has never actually casued that much trouble over its 7 years with us and stands at only 76k on the clock.....

I'd say that I would agree with just about everything you said regarding your comparisons between the pug and Megane, you've obviously done your homework.
I still think the Megane would be the safer bet though assuming you are competent and able to do your own maintenance, some of the 307cc electrical problems I've read about on Peugeot forums make pretty scary reading.
I guess my situation is different than most others in that I am an engineer and own 2 cars giving me the best of both worlds having been unable to find a satisfactory single car compromise.
I run a 1.4 206 HDI as daily hack for driving to work, doing the shopping, taking rubbish to the dump and driving around town, it averages a true 50+mpg, has an annual road tax of £30 and is cheap to insure.
My 2.0 litre Megane is much more sophisticated, comfortable and of course is a convertible that I will use for other more pleasurable journeys.
Gotta say the Megane with it's leather comfort pack is really comfortable on long journeys, the engine is a gem in the power delivery smoothness department, there is very little wind noise and not much rattles although the rear view mirror does blur slightly over bumps.
I've heard some people say that body roll is an issue but I haven't found that at all, OK so I don't tend to fling it around corners too aggressively but I have my moments and I gotta say I'm pretty pleased with the way it drives.
BTW apologies for going off topic.