1.9 Dci Clunky Gear selection
Posted: Mon Dec 22, 2008 12:38 am
Hi.
Since I've had my Megane 1.9Dci 04 reg Sport Hatch selecting 3rd gear has never been the most pleasant part of driving the car. It doesn't much like being rushed into selecting 3rd, and I wondered if this was normal or whether it's something I should be concerned about?
It seems to be mostly when change up from 2nd to 3rd, and occasionally it will slot into gear without a problem, other times the gear stick will kick back on going into gear (only what you feel through your hand holding the gearknob, it's not a violent kick), and other times it will give a less than reassuring slight crunch on going into gear. It is mostly 3rd gear it's like this with, but I'm fairly sure it is similar to a lesser extent with a couple of other gears. It's also mostly when the temperature is cold and the car hasn't warmed up properly.
Is it just a fact that the gearbox takes a while to get up to optimal operating temperature? Or could it be something more sinister such as the synchromesh failing? It hasn't got any worse in the year or so I've had the car, it's just disappointing that an otherwise decent drive is sometimes let down by a clunky, stubborn gear change.
I've read comments on this forum and other websites that the Dci's gearbox doesn't like to be rushed and is a bit clunky, but not read anywhere specifics about 3rd gear being the most stubborn gear of them all!
Any comments would be appreciated.
Since I've had my Megane 1.9Dci 04 reg Sport Hatch selecting 3rd gear has never been the most pleasant part of driving the car. It doesn't much like being rushed into selecting 3rd, and I wondered if this was normal or whether it's something I should be concerned about?
It seems to be mostly when change up from 2nd to 3rd, and occasionally it will slot into gear without a problem, other times the gear stick will kick back on going into gear (only what you feel through your hand holding the gearknob, it's not a violent kick), and other times it will give a less than reassuring slight crunch on going into gear. It is mostly 3rd gear it's like this with, but I'm fairly sure it is similar to a lesser extent with a couple of other gears. It's also mostly when the temperature is cold and the car hasn't warmed up properly.
Is it just a fact that the gearbox takes a while to get up to optimal operating temperature? Or could it be something more sinister such as the synchromesh failing? It hasn't got any worse in the year or so I've had the car, it's just disappointing that an otherwise decent drive is sometimes let down by a clunky, stubborn gear change.
I've read comments on this forum and other websites that the Dci's gearbox doesn't like to be rushed and is a bit clunky, but not read anywhere specifics about 3rd gear being the most stubborn gear of them all!
Any comments would be appreciated.